Skip to main content

 

“The Speculative Fiction Indie Novella Championship (SFINCS, pronounced “sphinx”) is a yearly competition to recognize, honor, and celebrate the talent and creativity present in the indie community. We are a sister competition to both SPFBO and SPSFC, and we highlight greatness in the novella format in all areas of speculative fiction (fantasy, science fiction, horror, etc.).” – From the official SFINCS website.

Note: The following review contains only my personal thoughts as a judge and does not reflect the views of the team as a whole.

 

REVIEW

Silence is Silver by Andrew Watson is a tightly-focused epic fantasy novella that stands as an entry point to his popular Shadowbinders series. There’s always a risk with prequel novellas, particularly in a contest setting, that they will fail to stand on their own and be impenetrable to new readers. SiS happily avoids the usual pitfalls, featuring a straightforward plot and worldbuilding that feels accessible without relying on dense infodumping to create a sense of itself. While there are several things to recommend SiS, however, ultimately I did find it to be lacking in a few key areas: notably it felt as though it could have stood a further edit, and at times the prose and certain worldbuilding concepts felt underconsidered or came off as unintentionally funny. That said, it’s very clear Watson is a talent and that he shows much promise as a writer.

In SiS, we follow a boy named Bas as he struggles to live up to the expectations of the harsh, survivalist culture he belongs to. This culture–the Urdahl–value the kinship between generational cohorts over blood ties, with each cohort under the guidance of an assigned mother figure. Even the kinship between cohorts is contingent, however, with character traits such as mercy, kindness, and introspection denigrated in favour of ruthlessness and self-interest. If a community-oriented action would risk harm or loss to the self, it is not Urdahl. Bas fails to live up to these expectations in several ways. Although undeniably a gifted survivalist and warrior, his empathy for his cohort–particularly his friends Eri and Mei–as well as his compassion and sense of communal responsibility, set him apart from the others. This difference becomes critically apparent when Bas and the rest of his generation must participate in a series of coming-of-age rituals that involve tests of endurance and courage. Though the strictures of cultural expectation warn Bas away from aiding his friends, he’s nonetheless compelled to do so, risking both his life and his future status within the community.

In many ways, SiS is a character piece. The plot is fairly straightforward (boy partiCover of Andrew Watson's Silence is Silver. A bald man sits on a bare mountain, crosslegged beneath a red stone with a round hole in it. The sky beyond is an ominous, clouded dark blue and the digital painting features rich colours that communicate a sense of the epic.cipates in coming of age ceremony, testing his skills and also his community ties), with some predictable developments that nonetheless manage to tug on the heartstrings by the time we reach the novella’s denouement. The focus here is on Bas and the question of whether he will manage to find a place within Urdahl culture, or if he will be ostracized from the community. Bas is an easy character to follow and root for: he questions the often ridiculous and self-sabotaging dictates of his culture all while demonstrating a child’s desperation to belong, and it’s clear he genuinely cares for those around him, valuing the unique perspectives and talents of his friends in a way that we don’t see from most of the Urdahl (Eri is a significant exception, and is a huge influence on Bas). There’s a sense by the novella’s conclusion that certain values and facets of Bas’s personality have been reinforced, while a perhaps dangerous single-mindedness has been seeded within him.

Although the book does stand alone and provide enough of a conclusion to the main storyline that I found it satisfying, there are some questions raised in the novella that do go unanswered, presumably because they form part of the larger narrative at work in Shadowbinders. One such plot thread involves a vision Bas receives as part of his initiation. In the vision, Bas sees the elders (and others) of the Urdahl brutally slaughtered–seemingly a premonition of a disastrous future. When Bas tries to warn one of the elders of what he’s seen, the elder’s response is that the visions are private and that he doesn’t want to know about it. If Bas wants to do something to avoid the future he foresaw, the elder suggests, he should try and avert that future himself. The sequence has the feel of something that’s intended to communicate character motivation in the main series (at a guess, Bas is somewhat of a tragic figure, doomed to cause the future he attempts to avert). The lack of an answer on this (and a few other, minor points) may bother readers who prefer to have the whole story, but I felt that it was largely successful as a means of teasing the larger story, and I was neither surprised nor disappointed that we didn’t get a clear answer here.

No matter how many times Maut Tenl told him to contain his emotions, Eri couldn’t when talking about stories.

In terms of the worldbuilding, there was much that intrigued me about the Urdahl, though equally they felt a little underconsidered. The sequence in which Bas confronts the elder, for example, might have imparted a richness to Urdahl beliefs around things like privacy and the sacred, but instead the elder’s reaction came off as absurd and a little Pythonesque. I love a hint of humour (and particularly Pythonesque humour) to break up a text and add levity to a dour setting, but here it felt both unintentional and a little like an authorial shrug (the elder doesn’t care to know or interfere because the author both needs him not to interfere, and also hasn’t established a stronger reason for him not to do so). The metaphorical shrug we get from the elder feels counter, also, to the intense control Urdahl leaders appear to exert over those beneath them, and since one of the elders demonstrates elsewhere in the novella that they’re willing to bend the rules to get their own way, it also felt unlikely from a character perspective.

I often find that survivalist and warrior cultures in fantasy and sci-fi are difficult to take seriously. Typically, this is because a particular group is so antagonistic, so violent, or so individualistic that it’s unlikely they would have continued to successfully exist in the form presented in a given text (though I adore Star Trek, the Klingons are a prime example, and I find the Klingons most enjoyable when the show recognizes their ridiculousness). A little of that was present here, but more often I found it was the execution that pulled me out of the story. From the get, it’s clear the reader is meant to take the Urdahl Very Seriously and that life as one of them is no piece of cake. The novella’s chapters all feature Urdahl proverbs that delight in warfare, resilience, bloodshed. Unfortunately, many of these (as well as the repeated refrain of “it [he/she/this] was of the Urdahl) begin to slide into unintentional comedy. The first proverb, “Pain is a lie. Told to us by weakness,” feels melodramatic, while a later variation (“Pain is inevitable”) is too generic a truth to feel meaningful. Several such sayings and moments likewise don’t make much sense once parsed (e.g. “dwelling is an idle mind,” “from ashes comes armour”), though at an initial glance they appear striking. It should be said though, that for all that I’m being very critical of these pieces, they do all convey very strongly a particular feel. Probably, just by reading these, you’ve gained an immediate sense of the Urdahl and of the role they occupy in the text (and presumably Shadowbinders as a whole).

While I did find that both the above issues, as well as occasional grammatical problems and redundancies, pulled me out of the story, or skewed the tone in a way I suspect was unintended, there is a strong narrative flow and I was left with the impression of Watson as a talented writer who shows a lot of promise and potential if he continues to dedicate himself to working on the precision of his writing and worldbuilding. The popularity of the series suggests there’s a strong readership for Watson’s work, and I would be interested to read future stories from him. I did absolutely adore the author’s note at the end, with its powerful message about storytelling. The importance of stories in the shaping of our lives was a subtle theme throughout SiS that came through well and that I found easy to invest in, leaving me curious about Bas and about whether that thematic element is present in the Shadowbinders series writ large. The dynamic between Eri and Bas was well-handled, and while I had an inkling of how that story element would turn out, knowing the conclusion didn’t limit my emotional reaction (as ought to be the case in a tragedy!).

Buy Silence is Silver on Bookshop.org
Add Silence is Silver on Goodreads

Steve Hugh Westenra

Steve is a trans author of fantasy, science fiction, and horror (basically, if it’s weird he writes it). He grew up on the eldritch shores of Newfoundland, Canada, and currently lives and works in (the slightly less eldritch) Montreal. He holds advanced degrees in Russian Literature, Medieval Studies, and Religious Studies. As a reader, Steve’s tastes are eclectic. He enjoys anything that could be called speculative, including fantasy, sci-fi, and horror, but has been known to enjoy a good mystery as well as literary fiction. He’s always excited to try something new or that pushes boundaries, particularly from marginalized authors. Steve is passionate about queer representation, Late Antiquity, and spiders.

Leave a Reply